How to Mix First and Third Person POV

Sat Jun 24 2017

About a week ago, a reader sent me this question about mixing POVs within a novel:

One of my writing pals has recently started a novel and has chosen to use one first-person pov and one third-person limited pov. The good news is that both types of viewpoint were introduced early, and that the unorthodox viewpoint style didn't jar me as much as I thought it would. It also serves to differentiate the characters pretty well so that their voices aren't indistinct.

Despite being unable to find any specific reason not to use this method, it's so... unorthodox. However, all the reasons I can think of to switch to all first-person or all third-person don't seem to apply here. Can such an unorthodox point of view work?

I have to admit, my first instinct was to discourage such attempts as foolhardy, because first- and third-person POV feel so different. How could they possibly work well together?

Except, people break the supposed "rules" of writing all the time and get away with it. So the real question here is not can it work, but when it works, why? And what can we learn from that?

Understand the rules to break the rules

As a rule about rule-breaking, you can break any rule of writing so long as you're doing it for effect. Broken rules suddenly work when the emotional effect evoked in the reader by breaking the rules is precisely the effect you want.

Which means that to understand how we might get away with mixing first- and third-person POVs, we'd better understand how each one "breaks" the other.

I wrote an article on what POV is for last year that covers this in some depth, so I won't rehash it all here. Suffice it to say that if you compare first- and third-person styling, you find this:

The difference between these POVs is fundamentally a difference about emotional distance and information control.

Understand those two axes, and the answer to that "when it works, why?" question becomes pretty straightforward.

Emotional distance

First-person narration has the viewpoint character telling you the story directly, in their own voice. Often, the character also lets you in on their inner-most thoughts. It is a very intimate narration style, and brings readers emotionally close to the viewpoint character.

By contrast, third-person holds them at distance. In third-person narration the reader's view of the characters is mediated by an (often anonymous and disembodied) narrator. The presence of that intermediary puts one level of separation between you and the characters, which in turn tends to diminish your emotional connection to them.

Information control

Third-person narration shares information pretty freely with readers. This is particularly so when the story uses an omniscient narrator, who is free to tell you anything, at any time, about anyone or any event in the story's world. Third-person narration has a way of laying all its cards on the table, as it were.

First-person narration, however, necessarily limits the information to only what the viewpoint character knows. Since the character is telling you the story, they can't tell you anything they themselves aren't aware of. All kinds of things can be happening--and typically are--outside of the first-person narrator's view. It should be pretty easy to see how a writer can use that limitation to create mysteries and otherwise hide stuff from the reader.

Guidelines for POV mixing

With that in mind, a story could benefit from using a mixed POV style if any of the following are true:

As far as how to mix them, I have two suggestions:

More options?

I would not be at all surprised if other people can come up with additional scenarios in which POV-mixing can work. If you have some, please share them in the comments! And if your particular scenario doesn't seem to fit the guidelines, that's ok. Just think about your story and what you need from it in terms of emotional distance and information control. Let your conclusions guide you to the right POV choices.

Thanks again to the reader who sent in this question. It was fun to think about, and I learned something about writing in the process!

And to everyone else: I love doing reader's choice articles, so send me your questions!


Previous Articles

How to Write a Memoir

Should I use 3rd Omniscient within 3rd Limited?

Piano Man's Unexpected Writing Lesson

How Exposition Breaks Empathy

How to Handle Time Skips in Your Novel

How Trust Affects Mysteries and Plot Holes

How to End Books in a Series

Finding the Finish Line

Chasing Perfection

Finding Your Novel's Starting Line

What-if: the Foundation of Fiction

Overcoming Writer's Block

There are No Throwaway Details

In Support of Inventory Drafts

Why Characters Must Pay for Their Sins

To Think or Not to Think

Never give up. Never surrender!

Why a bad day makes for a good story

Is Your Book a Bargain?

Weak Verbs are the Path to the Dark Side

Death by Backstory

So You Want to be a Writer

Falling Through the Cracks

Road Trip!

Don't Write That Scene!

The Paths of the Pentacle

The Pentacle of Plotting

The Ideal Novelist's Degree

Can You Repeat That?

Limited vs. Omniscient Third Person POV

Get Out of My Head!

Point of view, names, and amnesia

Practical Plotting

A Former Literary Agent on Plotting

What's in a name?

Make new friends but keep the old

Fight, Fight, Fight!

On Reading, Imagination, and Pokemon Go

Facing the Harsh Truths About Publishing

6 1/2 Harsh Truths About Publishing

Revising for Pacing

Using Backstory Effectively

Are You Asking the Right Question About Backstory?

No Place for Placeholders

Three Reasons Why Novels Fail

What a Coincidence

What Information Theory Teaches Writers

If You're a Writer You May be an Empath

Emotion Takes Time

Two Body Language Ninja Moves

Superman Syndrome

It's Gonna Cost You

All Beef, No Filler

How to Use Flashbacks Right

How to Reward Children in Your Writing, Part 4

How to Reward Children in Your Writing, Part 3

How to Reward Children in Your Writing, Part 2

How to Reward Children in Your Writing, Part 1

How to Pick Your Point of View

What is Point of View For, Anyway?

Why Actions Speak Louder than Words

Relaunching My Website